How to spot grey market diversion

Grey market diversion shows in the gap between the market a code was shipped to and where it was scanned. How to track it with two records and a threshold.

Grey market diversion is spotted by comparing the market a product was shipped to with the place its code was scanned. Both the product and the label are genuine; the only thing wrong is where the product is. A verification check will return "genuine" here; what reveals diversion is putting the shipping record and the scan record side by side.

A typical case: a batch shipped to one market under different price terms goes on sale in another. Regional prices are disrupted, and that market's authorised distributor ends up competing in its own territory with the brand's own product. Other forms, such as out-of-territory sales and parallel trade, and a step-by-step detection method are covered in our channel diversion guide.

Why is verification not enough?

When the code is scanned, the system says "genuine", and it is right. The product came out of the brand's own production. To see diversion, a separate piece of information is needed: which market this code was sent to. If that is not in the record, diversion stays invisible however often the code is scanned.

Which records are needed?

Two records are enough. The shipping record states which market and which distributor the batch or unit went to. The scan record states where and when the code was scanned. The shipping record should not rely on the target market planned at production; it should be written when the shipment actually takes place. Plan and actual shipment are usually the same; diversion starts where the two part ways.

What does diversion look like in the record?

A single scan says nothing. A consumer on holiday, a product received as a gift or a business trip leave the same trace. What matters is a large number of codes from the same batch being scanned in a region that batch was never shipped to.

This trace also differs from a copied code. With a copied code, the same number is scanned again and again in different places. With diversion, each number is scanned once or a few times, but most of the numbers are in the wrong region. How a copied code is detected is covered in serial number verification.

How is the threshold set?

The same threshold does not suit every region. In areas with heavy cross-border trade, in tourist regions, or in online channels that ship across borders, the expected share of out-of-territory scans is higher. The threshold is set separately for each region from a few periods of scan data, and when it is changed, the reason is recorded.

What is the finding for?

In a conversation with a distributor, voicing a general suspicion and showing how many units from which batch were scanned in which region lead to different outcomes. The second moves the discussion onto concrete data. If the distribution agreement contains a territorial restriction, the record is the basis for enforcing it. Whether a sale amounts to an infringement in law is assessed separately under the agreement and the applicable rules.

Diversion in the Tagvex record

In Tagvex, every product, or every batch, carries its own number. Dispatch and receipt records at the line exit, warehouse, distributor and dealer are collected in a single record, and when the product is scanned with a phone camera, that scan is added with its country. If a target market (a country or a country group) is assigned to the batch or code, a scan outside that market opens a market mismatch finding. The result the consumer sees does not change, because the product is genuine; the finding appears only in the brand team's panel. The panel compares the target market with the country of scan by product and batch. Codes scanned outside the region they were shipped to, or in an unexpected place, are flagged, and channel diversion is reported periodically.

Meeting request

The right numbering level for your product is set through a needs analysis.

The first meeting reviews your product, sales channels and the risks you face, and recommends a suitable method.

Request a meeting